I'm not a person who holds a grudge, but.....
I believe that everyone should get a second chance, but .....
I know that we can't lump everyone together, but...
We are making a point and feel bad about making generalizations. The generalizations reveal our prejudices. And they may not be racial prejudices. It could be feelings about the people in the next town or people in a different economic class than us. (Sure there are some rich people who don't let it go to their head, BUT most think that they are better than us.) (There are some people who really need public assistance, BUT most could get a job if they wanted to.)
I have heard it said that everything before the BUT is a lie. I'm not sure that I believe that, BUT it seems that our true opinions are reflected in the second half.
The problem with the BUT is that it gets in the way of our being honest with ourselves. We see ourselves for something that we are not. If we are truly going to love our neighbors, we need to acknowledge that our prejudices exist and work through them. We can't pretend that we are the ones who have none.
I think that a good start is that anytime that we are making a but statement, we need to try to turn it around.
Instead of saying "I am not someone who holds a grudge, BUT what they did is unforgivable" We should say "What they did is unforgivable, BUT I am not someone who holds a grudge."
Instead of saying "I believe that everyone should get a second chance, BUT this is just too much." We should say, "They have made this mistake before, BUT I believe that everyone deserves a second chance."
I think by turning around the statement we focus more on the exception than the rule. We see individuals more than groups. We see how people can overcome their circumstances, not be defined by them.
Everything that comes before the BUT doesn't count. In the hymn Amazing Grace we sing:
I once was lost BUT now I'm found.
was blind BUT now I see.
In our relationship with God, what comes first doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is what comes next. I am a sinner BUT now I am forgiven. God knows what part of the statement belongs after the BUT and we should too.